I didn't set out to create a pie specific storytime, but as I pulled in different books about eating/food, I found three that would work together. I was able to do this fun storytime at two family storytimes (at different locations)
Books
Pie in the Sky
by Lois Ehelert
All for Pie, Pie for all
by David Martin; illustrated by Valeri Gorbachev
I Know an Old Lady Who Swallowed a Pie
by Alison Jackson, illustrated by Judith Byron Schachner
I actually used the Flannel Board I made several years ago
Songs and Movement
Hello, Hello
If I was a Bird
My Hands
The Ants Go Marching
Colors in Motion
My Hands say, "Let's Play!"
Magnet Board
Five Little Apples
Play and Learn
Playdough!
Pom Poms!